The respective campaign launches of the two major parties on Sunday revealed they are in the same political panic—how to win the votes of young people whose overwhelming concern is the housing crisis.
In this cost-of-living election, the cost of housing is the single biggest issue, accounting for half of the inflation Aussies have suffered.
In desperation, both the Liberals and Labor announced desperate policies to try to convince young voters they care.
Except there’s one problem: the two parties are a duopoly, a uniparty with two names, or, as the Australian Citizens Party’s NSW Senate candidate Dr Andy Schmulow says, “they are the Liberal Party and the diet Liberal Party—lower calories, same great liberal taste”.
Over 25 years the duopoly has created the housing crisis using deliberate government policy, both inflating house prices and then intervening to stop them falling.
They are, as usual, taking young voters for mugs, devising policies to give them a ramp into the meatgrinder of the current broken housing market, where they can trade rental stress for mortgage stress, but at all costs not fixing the actual housing crisis.
Labor is offering to make 5 per cent deposits available for all first homebuyers, while the Liberals are proposing to make mortgage payments tax deductible for all first homebuyers.
The net effect of these policies will be to make it easier for young families to feed the banks’ massive profit-making mortgage machines, with taxpayer support.
Add in some token lip service to constructing more houses, which both major parties have proved is easy to promise, and even easier to fail to deliver.
What is the duopoly not proposing to do? Actually bring down the cost of housing, that’s what.
They are not proposing to end the rigging of the CPI that started in 1998, when land was removed from the calculation of inflation, so that as house prices skyrocketed from 3-4 times household income in 2000 to more than 10 times today, the Reserve Bank was able to keep interest rates low and feed the bubble.
They are not proposing to reform the tax system to end the advantage of investors over homebuyers by phasing out the capital gains tax discount Peter Costello introduced in 1999, which by 2004 had already caused house prices to rise so much that they disconnected from affordability.
The Productivity Commission warned John Howard and Peter Costello in 2004 that the CGT discount had been a mistake, but they were too cowardly to change it because that would cause house prices to fall, leaving the problem to get drastically worse to the point it has broken the economy.
They are not proposing to stop the bank regulator APRA from allowing the banks to hold lower capital against mortgages than any other loans. Since the 1990s, the balance of bank lending has turned upside down, from 70 per cent of loans going to business and 30 per cent to mortgages in 1990, to 30 per cent business loans and 70 per cent mortgages today, because APRA has made mortgages more profitable than all other lending.
They are not proposing to crack down on banking misconduct. Despite the 2018 banking royal commission, the banks are still knowingly writing so-called “liar loans” involving faked expenses and income, so they can keep pumping out those mortgages to desperate people unable to afford them.
The ACP’s policy solution includes ending government and bank policies that drive up house prices, establishing a public bank to invest in the biggest social and public housing construction program in history, and a moratorium on foreclosures so families don’t lose their homes.
The duopoly major parties are getting desperate because they are losing record votes, but they can’t solve the crisis because they won’t take on the banks.
The one party that does—ACP—is the one party that will truly fix the housing crisis.
On 3 May use your vote to support Citizens Party candidates, especially in the Senate where the ACP would use the balance of power on the cross bench to force the government to enact real solutions. Click here to view all of our candidates.